Ferdinand Tönnies Beneath and Beyond Post-Colonial Sociology. Or: Das Kind mit dem Bade ausschütten
Hauptsächlicher Artikelinhalt
Abstract
It is unwise ‘to throw the baby out with the bath water’, as an old saying goes. Critics have for a long time been throwing the baby out with the bath water as far as Ferdinand Tönnies is concerned, and this continues today. This essay is focused on potential postcolonial dismissals of Tönnies’ sociology. It seeks to show that Tönnies and his sociological thought are more subtle, complex, and interesting than any caricatured negative appreciation of his ideas can grasp. He should not be ejected from the sociological canon on simplifying and spurious grounds. The essay makes a case for Tönnies’ sociology not as an enemy of postcolonial concerns in sociology but as a potential ally of them. This is done by considering Tönnies as a creative post-Kantian cosmopolitan thinker, one whose categories can be applied in sensitive ways to non-Western and post-colonial contexts, such as in India, and one whose concepts can potentially continue to animate interpretations of imperial and colonial phenomena.
Keywords: Tönnies, post-colonial, classical sociology, canon, imperialism, India
Bibliographie: Inglis, David: Ferdinand Tönnies Beneath and Beyond Post-Colonial Sociology. Or: Das Kind mit dem Bade ausschütten, Kieler sozialwissenschaftliche Revue, 1-2025, S. 31-47.
Artikel-Details
Literatur
Adair-Toteff, Christopher (1995): Ferdinand Tönnies: Utopian Visionary. In: Sociological Theory,13, 1, pp. 58–65.
Adair-Toteff, Christopher (2016): The Anthem Companion to Ferdinand Tönnies. London: Anthem.
Adair-Toteff, Christopher (2023): Reintroducing Ferdinand Tönnies. London: Routledge.
Alatas, Syed F./Sinha, Vineeta (2017): Sociological Theory Beyond the Canon. London: Palgrave.
Al-Hardan, Anaheed (2018): The Sociological Canon Reconfigured: Empire, Colonial Critique, and Contemporary Sociology. In: International Sociology 33, 5, pp. 545–557.
Anderson, Kevin B. (2010): Marx at the Margins. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Beck, Ulrich (2002): The Cosmopolitan Society and Its Enemies. In: Theory, Culture and Society 19, 1–2, pp. 17–44.
Bendix, Reinhard (1967): Tradition and Modernity Reconsidered. In: Comparative Studies in Society and History 9, 3, pp. 292–346.
Berg, Dag-Erik (2015): Caste, Hierarchy and Race inaWorld-Historical Perspective: Louis Dumont and His Critique of Max Weber. In: Journal of Intercultural Studies 36, 4, pp. 413–430.
Béteille, Andre (1986): Individualism and Equality. In: Current Anthropology 27, 2, pp. 121–128.
Bhambra, Gurminder K. (2007a): Rethinking Modernity. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
Bhambra, Gurminder K. (2007b): Sociology and Postcolonialism: Another “Missing” Revolution?. In: Sociology 41, 5, pp. 871–884.
Bhambra, Gurminder K. (2016): Postcolonial Reflections on Sociology. In: Sociology 50, 5, pp. 960–966.
Bhambra, Gurminder K./Holmwood, John (2021): Colonialism and Modern Social Theory. Cambridge: Polity.
Bhambra, Gurminder K./Narayan, John (2016): European Cosmopolitanism. London: Routledge.
Boatcã, Manuela/Costa, Sergio/Gutiérrez-Rodríguez, Encarnacion (2010): Introduction: Decolonizing European Sociology: Different Paths Towards a Pending Project. In: Boatcã, Manuela/Costa, Sergio/Gutiérrez-Rodríguez, Encarnacion (Eds.): Decolonizing European Sociology. London: Routledge, pp. 1–12.
Bond, Niall (2009): Gemeinschaft und Gesellschaft: The Reception of a Conceptual Dichotomy. In: Contributions to the History of Concepts 5, 2, pp. 162–186.
Bond, Niall (2012): Ferdinand Tönnies and Max Weber. In: Max Weber Studies 12, 1, pp. 25–58.
Bond, Niall (2013a): Ferdinand Tönnies and Enlightenment: A Friend or Foe of Reason? The European Legacy 18, 2, pp. 127–150.
Bond, Niall (2013b): Ferdinand Tönnies’ Appraisal of Karl Marx: Debts and Distance. In: Journal of Classical Sociology 13, 1, pp. 136–162.
Bond, Niall (2013c): Understanding Ferdinand Tönnies’ “Community and Society”. Social theory and political philosophy between enlighted liberal individualism and transfigured community. Berlin/New York: LIT.
Bond, Niall (2024a): Ferdinand Tönnies and the French Speaking World. In: Bond, Niall (Ed.): The Concept of Community in Global Perspective. Leiden: Brill, pp. 99–124.
Bond, Niall (2024b): Tönnies on the Tension between Community and Society During the First World War. In: Journal of Classical Sociology 24, 4, pp. 375–388.
Brewer, John D. (2007): Putting Adam Ferguson In His Place. In: The British Journal of Sociology 58, pp. 105–122.
Brobjer, Thomas H. (2004): Nietzsche’s Reading About Eastern Philosophy. In: The Journal of Nietzsche Studies 28, pp. 3–35.
Cahnman, Werner J. (1973): Ferdinand Tönnies. A New Evaluation. Leiden: Brill.
Carstens, Uwe (2013): Ferdinand Tönnies: Friese und Weltbürger. Eine Biographie. Bredstedt: Nordfriisk Instituut.
Chaudhury, S.K. (2015): Indian Sociology: Some Issues. In: Gupta, Surendra K./Kumar, Vinay Srivastava (Eds.): Exploring Indian Society. Delhi: Indus Publications, pp. 169–182.
Chibber, Vivek (2013): Postcolonial Theory and the Specter of Capital. London: Verso.
Connell, Raewyn W. (1997): Why is Classical Theory Classical?. In: American Journal of Sociology 102, 6, pp. 1511–1557.
Connell, Raewyn (2007): Southern Theory. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Connell, Raewyn (2010): Periphery and Metropole in the History of Sociology. In: Sociologisk Forskning 47, 1, pp. 72–86.
Dahrendorf, R. (1965): Gesellschaft und Demokratie in Deutschland. München: R. Piper & Co.
Dawson, Matt (2021): Whiteness, Judaism and the Challenge of the Postcolonial Critique. In: Thesis Eleven 167, 1, pp. 145–148.
Devapriya, Uditha (2023): Neither Gemeinschaft Nor Gesellschaft: Sri Lanka Under British Rule’, Medium, March 27, https://udithadevapriya.medium.com/neither-gemeinschaft-nor-gesellschaftf7239b76225e [11. 03. 2025].
D’Souza, Victor S. (2006): Individuation in Indian Society: From Collective Identity to Individual Identity. In: Sociological Bulletin 55, 2, pp. 281–299.
Dumont, Louis (1980): Homo Hierarchicus. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Dumont, Louis (1986): Essays on Individualism. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Durkheim, Émile (1889): Ferdinand Tonnies. Gemeinschaft und Gesellschaft. In: Revue Philosophique de la France et de l’Étranger 27, pp. 416–422.
Felsch, Maximilian (2023): The Scientific Shortcomings of Postcolonial Theory. In: International Studies 60, 1, pp. 113–130.
Ferraresi, Furio (2017): Between Hobbes and Spinoza: Research on the Philosophical Matrix of Ferdinand Tönnies’ Sociological Categories. In: Scienza & Politica. Per Una Storia Delle Dottrine 29, 56. https://doi.org/10.6092/issn.1825-9618/7103 [18. 03. 2025].
Giri, Ananta K. (Ed.) (2018): Beyond Cosmopolitanism. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
Go, Julian (2013a): For a Postcolonial Sociology. In: Theory and Society 42, 1, pp. 25–55.
Go, Julian (2013b): Postcolonial Sociology. Bingley: Emerald.
Go, Julian (2013c): Sociology’s Imperial Unconscious: The Emergence of American Sociology in the Context of Empire. In: Steinmetz, George (Ed.) (2013): Sociology and Empire: The Imperial Entanglements of a Discipline. Durham: Duke University Press, pp. 83–105.
Go, Julian (2016a): Global Sociology, Turning South: Perspectival Realism and the Southern Standpoint. In: Sociologica 10, 2, pp. 1–42.
Go, Julian (2016b): Postcolonial Thought and Social Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Go, Julian (2020): Race, Empire and Epistemic Exclusion: Or the Structures of Sociological Thought. In: Sociological Theory 38, 2, pp. 79–100.
Go, Julian (2023): Thinking Against Empire: Anticolonial Thought as Social Theory. In: British Journal of Sociology 74, 3, pp. 279–293.
Habermas, Jürgen (1997): Kant’s Idea of Perpetual Peace, With the Benefit of Two Hundred Years Hindsight. In: Bohman, James/Lutz-Bachmann, Matthias (Eds.): Perpetual Peace. Essays on Kant’s Cosmopolitan Ideal. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, pp. 113–154.
Hegde, Sasheej (2001): On the Tracks of Community and Identity. In: Jodhka, Surinder S. (Ed.): Community and Identities: Contemporary Discourses on Culture and Politics in India. Delhi: Sage, pp. 59–79.
Henricksen, Bruce (1992): Nomadic Voices: Conrad and the Subject of Narrative. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Hobsbawm, Eric/Ranger, Terence (2012): The Invention of Tradition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Inglis, David (2009): Cosmopolitan Sociology and the Classical Canon: Ferdinand Tönnies and the Emergence of Global Gesellschaft. In: British Journal of Sociology 96, 12, pp. 813–832.
Inglis, David (2014): Cosmopolitanism’s Sociology and Sociology’s Cosmopolitanism: Retelling the History of Cosmopolitan Theory from Stoicism to Durkheim and Beyond. In: Distinktion 15, 1, pp. 69–87.
Inglis, David (2026 forthcoming): Probing the Post-Colonial: Some Problems and Risks of Post-Colonial and De-Colonising Sociologies, and Some Ways to Overcome Them. In: Maddanu, Simone/Yassine, Rachid Id/Rebughin, Paolo (Eds.): The Routledge International Handbook of Post-Colonial Sociology. London: Routledge.
Inglis, David/ Robertson, Roland (2008): The Elementary Forms of Globality: Durkheim and the Emergence and Nature of Global Life. In: Journal of Classical Sociology 8, 1, pp. 5–25.
Inglis, David/Almila, Anna-Mari (2020): Sociological Masters of the World: For and Against ‘Global Sociology. In: Rassegna Italiana di Sociologia LXI, 4, pp. 741–769.
Jayaram, Narayana (2020): Towards Indigenization of an Uncertain Transplant: Hundred Years of Sociology in India. In: Tajseer 1, 2, pp. 99–122.
Kant, Immanuel (2006a): Idea for a Universal History from a Cosmopolitan Perspective. In: Kleingeld, Pauline (Ed.): Toward Perpetual Peace and Other Writings on Politics, Peace, and History. New Haven: Yale University Press, pp. 3–16.
Kant, Immanuel (2006b): Toward Perpetual Peace;A Philosophical Sketch. In: Kleingeld, Pauline (Ed.): Toward Perpetual Peace and Other Writings on Politics, Peace, and History. New Haven: Yale University Press, pp. 45–66.
Kemple, Thomas J./Mawani, Renisa (2009): The Sociological Imagination and its Imperial Shadows. In: Theory, Culture & Society 26, 7–8, pp. 228–49.
Klauke, Sebastian (2021): Zur linken Rezeptionsgeschichte von “Gemeinschaft und Gesellschaft” bis 1936: Eine Spurensuche. https://www.soziopolis.de/zur-linken-rezeptionsgeschichte-von-gemeinschaft-und-gesellschaft-bis-1936.html [18. 03. 2025].
Klauke, Sebastian (2024): Günther Rudolph – A Sketch of the Life and Work of a Tönnies Scholar in East Germany. In: Bond, Niall (Ed.): The Concept of Community in Global Perspective. Leiden: Brill, pp. 86–98.
König, Rene (1955): Die Begriffe Gemeinschaft und Gesellschaft bei Ferdinand Tönnies. In: Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie 7, pp. 348–420.
Kurasawa, Fuyuki (2003): Primitiveness and the Flight from Modernity: Sociology and the Avant-Garde in Inter-War France. In: Economy and Society 32, 1, pp. 7–28.
Lukacs, Georg (1980 [1962]): The Destruction of Reason. London: Merlin.
Manjapra, Kris (2014): Transnational Approaches to Global History:AView from the Study of German-Indian Entanglement. In: German History 32, 2, pp. 274–293.
Marx, Karl (1969): Colonialism and Modernization. Garden City: Anchor.
McLennan, Gregor (2003): Sociology, Eurocentrism and Postcolonial Theory. In: European Journal of Social Theory 6, 1, pp. 69–86.
McLennan, G. (2014): Complicity, Complexity, Historicism: Problems of Postcolonial Sociology. In: Postcolonial Studies 17, 4, pp. 451–464.
Meghji, Ali (2021): Decolonizing Sociology. Cambridge: Polity.
Mensch, Jennifer (2017): Caught between Character and Race: “Temperament” in Kant’s Lectures on Anthropology. In: Australian Feminist Law Journal 43, 1, pp. 125–144.
Mieder, Wolfgang/Hand, Wayland D. (1991): “(Don’t) Throw The Baby Out With The Bath Water”: The Americanization of a German Proverb and Proverbial Expression. In: Western Folklore 50, 4, pp. 361–400.
Mitzman, Arthur (1971): Tönnies and German Society, 1887–1914: From Cultural Pessimism to Celebration of the Volksgemeinschaft. In: Journal of the History of Ideas 32, 4, pp. 507–524.
Momin, A.R. (1978): Indian Sociology: Search for Authentic Identity. In: Sociological Bulletin 27, 2, pp. 154–172.
Moosavi, Leon (2020): The Decolonial Bandwagon and the Dangers of Intellectual Decolonisation. In: International Review of Sociology 30, 2, pp. 332–354.
Moosavi, Leon (2022): Turning the Decolonial Gaze Towards Ourselves: Decolonising the Curriculum and “Decolonial Reflexivity” in Sociology and Social Theory. In: Sociology 57, 1, pp. 137–156.
Mucha, Janusz (2012): Sociology of India, Sociology in India, Indian Sociology. In: Polish Sociological Review 178, pp. 145–150.
Pappenheim, Fritz (1959): The Alienation of Modern Man: An Interpretation Based on Marx and Tönnies. New York: Monthly Review Press.
Repp, Kevin (2000): Reformers, Critics and the Paths of German Modernity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rudolph, Günther (1968): Die Einwirkungen des ‘Kapitals’ von Karl Marx auf den bürgerlichen Demokraten Ferdinand Tönnies. In: Wirtschaftswissenschaft 5, pp. 760–778.
Rudolph, Günther (1990): Friedrich Nietzsche und Ferdinand Tönnies. “Der Wille zur Macht” widerlegt von den Positionen eines “Willens zur Gemeinschaft”. In: Rudolph, Günther (Ed.): Der Nietzsche-Kultus: Eine Kritik. Berlin: Akademie-Verlag, pp. 107–139.
Rudolph, Günther (1995) Die Philosophisch-Soziologischen Grundpositionen von Ferdinand Tönnies (1855–1936). Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte und Kritik der Bürgerlichen Soziologie. Hamburg: Rolf Fechner.
Samples, John (1987): Kant, Tönnies, and the Liberal Idea of Community in Early German Sociology. In: History of Political Thought 8, 2, pp. 245–262.
Santos, Boaventura D. S (2016): Epistemologies of the South. London: Routledge.
Seidman, Steven (2013): The Colonial Unconscious of Classical Sociology. In: Political Power and Social Theory 24, pp. 35–54.
Sharma, Chandan K./Borgohain, Bhaswati (2024): Indigenization and Vernacularization of Social Science in India: Revisiting the Debate. In: Postcolonial Studies 27, 2, pp. 229–247.
Smith, Andrew (2022): Tearing Asunder the Pretty Fancies of Capitalism: Reflections on Marx and Empire. In: Journal of Classical Sociology 22, 4, pp. 402–409.
Stafford, William (1994): Ferdinand Tönnies: ACandidate for the Canon?. In: Politics 14, 1, pp. 15–20.
Steinmetz, George (Ed.) (2013): Sociology and Empire: The Imperial Entanglements of a Discipline. Durham: Duke University Press.
Steinmetz, George (2014): The Sociology of Empires, Colonies, and Postcolonialism. In: Annual Review of Sociology 40, pp. 77–103.
Stoetzler, Marcel (Ed.) (2014): Antisemitism and the Constitution of Sociology. Omaha: University of Nebraska Press.
Tönnies, Ferdinand (1957 [1887]): Community and Society, transl. and ed. by Charles D. Loomis. London: Routledge.
Tönnies, Ferdinand (1961 [1909]): Custom: An Essay on Social Codes. New York: Free Press.
Turner, Bryan S. (1974): The Concept of Social “Stationariness”: Utilitarianism and Marxism. In: Science and Society 38, 1, pp. 3–18.
Uimonen, Paula (2020): Decolonising Cosmopolitanism. In: Critique of Anthropology 40, 1, pp. 81–101.
Venkatesen, Soumhya (2006): Shifting Balances in a “Craft Community”: The Mat Weavers of Pattamadai, South India. In: Contributions to Indian Sociology 40, 1, pp. 63–89.
Zimmerman, Andrew (2013): German Sociology and Empire: From Internal Colonization to Overseas Colonization and Back Again. In: Steinmetz, George (Ed.) (2013): Sociology and Empire: The Imperial Entanglements of a Discipline. Durham: Duke University Press, pp. 83–105.